Two weeks have passed since Thanksgiving and I have not seen It’s a Wonderful Life advertised even once! That could mean that I haven’t been paying attention, or it could mean that we will be spared this season. What was once considered a box office failure has become, from the 1970s, an annual classic — a movie more widely aired than even the Wizard of Oz. George Bailey’s struggle to make sense of his life and Clarence Odbody’s pursuit of his wings resonate at a deep level with some people. For all of its maudlin sentimentality and Hallmark scenery, the movie does have a message we need to hear, particularly as we struggle to find our way out of the most difficult economic times since the great depression. As George Bailey learns, life can be tough, but there is the possibility of a wonderful life even in the face of struggle.
William Butler Yeats begins “Sailing to Byzantium” with an often repeated line, “That is no country for old men.” He looks with longing on the young as they pursue love and enjoy sensuous pursuits while he must confront the reality of his declining health and the changing circumstances of his life. He is no longer the man he was, yet he is defiant in his refusal to accept being “An aged man … a paltry thing, A tattered coat upon a stick….” No scarecrow here. Yeats chooses to embrace life, to find its deeper meaning, and ultimately, to find a voice that transcends his own life. George Bailey must learn that his life is measured by his relationships and his contributions to his community. George loves and is loved in return; that is his voice that transcends his own life. In the end George Bailey, like Yeats, chooses to embrace life — and yes, Clarence gets his wings.
As you can probably tell by now, I don’t like this movie, and I can think of a dozen or so Christmas movies I prefer to watch; however, there is something worth noting in George Bailey’s struggle. It’s our struggle too. Measuring ourselves by externals, whether achievements or acquisitions, can lead to great disappointment. In whatever corner of the planet we inhabit, we do have the potential at every moment to make a difference. That difference defines us. How do you choose to live this season? What will you and others remember about this Christmas? That’s an interesting question, isn’t it?
Jesus was born in a stable, fled his homeland with his family as a toddler seeking political asylum, worked with his hands as a tradesman, died a brutal death, and changed the world. The first Christmas is only a Hallmark moment after the fact. The reality was neither comfortable nor comforting, but it began a movement that continues to inspire billions. In spite of popular misconceptions, the Christian religion is vibrant and growing throughout the world. It is growing because Jesus speaks to the hearts of the millions upon millions who are yearning for something more. The crèche on the mantel, with its baby Jesus, reminds us of a story in which power and humility combine to show us a God of love who is willing to be one of us — to be one of us in every way, in all of the messiness of human existence. That is the power of this story, and that is its appeal. The God in the manger is the God who redeems our lives, giving them meaning beyond ourselves. And it is this God who points us beyond self to true community. In so doing, he calls us to be like him — the person for others.
I’m not so self-deceiving as believe that I am that person for others that I believe Jesus is calling me to be — not in this season nor any other — nor do I think I’m going to accomplish anything similar to the child in the manger, no matter how much I try. But I am self-aware enough to know that I like Christmas. I like the lights on the streets, the music in the stores, our own Christmas tree decorated with ornaments collected over a lifetime, and yes, I like opening presents. In short, I buy into the whole Christmas thing. But amidst all the lights and noise, I am reminded, again and again, of the yearning in the hearts of the people I meet.
We want Christmas to last. The shops begin the celebration earlier each year. Our neighbors keep their lights lit well into January. What we are seeking to prolong is the peace on earth and goodwill to all people that we experience so briefly for a few wintry evenings. Peace and goodwill. That, George finds, is the result of a lifetime lived for others. That is the life lived by the child in the manger — a life we are called to emulate. Maybe the question we should be asking isn’t, what will we remember about this Christmas? Maybe the real question is, what will people remember about me this Christmas?